Michael Ryder’s day with the Stanley Cup puts dent on the side of the bowl. At a public viewing of the Cup on the rooftop of hotel near Ryder’s hometown of Bonavista, Newfoundland, the trophy took a tumble off when the table it was sitting on collapsed. The fall put a nice little dent in the top of the trophy. VIDEO HERE
PLEASE NOTE: This is not the Original Stanley Cup, this is the Presentation Cup that was dented.
The Presentation Cup was made in the late 1960s by Carl Poul Peterson.

Carl Poul Petersen is the most famous Stanley Cup engraver. Born in Denmark, he and his wife moved to Montreal in 1929, finding employment with Henry Birks & Sons. In 1937 he branched out on his own with sons Arno, Ole and John Paule. By the mid 1940s Carl Poul Petersen’s work became world famous for his fine craftsmanship.

With the NHL head offices then still in Montreal, the NHL commissioned Petersen to redesign the “Stovepipe Cup” first in 1947 with a final redesign as we know it in 1957. In 1968 he was commissioned to create a replica of the original Stanley Cup bowl, due to the aging structure’s fragility. Until 1961 Petersen’s shop was the home of the Stanley Cup, packed away out of sight. Petersen was the sole Stanley Cup engraver until his death in 1977. His family, specifically son Arno, continued the engraving until 1979 when they shut down the famous silversmith shop.

The NHL then hired Montreal based Boffey Promotions, known best for the work of owner Eric Boffey and later son Doug Boffey. But since 1989 only Louise St. Jacques, an employee turned part-owner of Boffey Promotions, engraves the Stanley Cup. She is also in charge of creating the 13 inch replica Cups given to players and other team officials. She alone recreated the entire Stanley Cup when the Hockey Hall of Fame had a complete replica produced in 1994 so that fans visiting the HHOF could see a Stanley Cup should the real Cup be on tour.

By the way, the term engraved is technically wrong even though it is universally used in association with the Stanley Cup. In actuality, each letter is individually stamped using a letter bit and small hammer. Boffey Inc. uses the original punching tools as Petersen used since the redesign in 1947. These tools are never used for any other project; they are the exclusive domain of the Stanley Cup.

Petersen and now St. Jacques are also the only people who engrave all other NHL trophies.