St Nicholas Hockey Club players Hobey Baker, Russell Ellis and Tun Fox.

Hobart Amery Hare "Hobey" Baker (1892–1918) was a Princeton University graduate from Wissahickon, Pennsylvania and played rover for the St. Nicholas Hockey Club in the American Amateur Hockey League in 1914–15 & 1915–16. He died in a post-war aviation accident in Toul, France.

Russell Ogden Ellis (1892–1966) was a center forward from Toronto, Ontario and represented the St. Nicholas HC in the AAHL in 1913–14, 1914–15, 1915–16 and in one game during the 1916–17 season.

Edwin Tunnicliff "Tun" Fox (1887–1967) was a Princeton University gradute from Cape Vincent, New York and played right wing for the St. Nicholas HC in the AAHL in 1914–15 & 1915–16.